When Compensation Becomes the Strategy

Broader scientific context

Protective movement, practiced habits and the return to useful options

A movement solution can help someone keep going through pain, weakness or uncertainty. When the situation changes, recovery may include learning when to keep that solution, when to vary it and when to build another.

Key Takeaways

A useful strategy should remain a choice

Compensation is not automatically a fault. Judge what the strategy makes possible and what it costs in the current task.

Protective movement can persist, but persistence is not universal and does not identify its cause.

Strength, movement capacity and practiced skill answer different questions; recovery may require work in more than one domain.

A movement that changes with a cue has shown responsiveness. Retention and transfer need later, task-relevant checks.

Graded exposure can help test expectations within an appropriate clinical plan; it does not mean overriding symptoms or restrictions.

Retraining can preserve a useful solution while developing alternatives that support meaningful, repeatable participation.

Compensation begins as a solution

A lifter shortens the descent to avoid an uncomfortable shoulder position. A runner uses less knee bend after injury. Both have redistributed the work to complete a task within current limits.

Judge that solution by what it allows and what it costs now. It may respect a restriction, preserve participation or accommodate a lasting change in capacity. It may also limit an activity the person wants to regain.

In an experiment with 16 volunteers, Moseley and Hodges tested arm movements before, during and after experimentally evoked back pain. Participants whose abdominal postural strategy became less variable during pain retained that change after the pain stopped. Pain-related cognitions also differed between responses [1].

Reassess both current capacity and available movement options. Weakness, stiffness, symptoms, restrictions and prior practice can each influence the strategy an athlete uses.

Injury Is More Than Tissue Damage covers the physiological effects of injury and pain. Here, the focus is how practice can expand useful movement options.

A movement strategy can persist after the original reason has changed

When an athlete repeatedly avoids a position, explore why: expected pain, limited strength, efficiency, earlier instructions or a continuing need for protection. Several factors may operate together.

Observe the pattern
Identify the position or action the person repeatedly avoids.
Explore the reason
Consider current capacity, protection, expectations and earlier instructions.
Ask about choice
Distinguish a preferred strategy from one the person cannot vary.

Jacobs, Henry and Nagle compared ten people with chronic low back pain with ten people without it during 75 rapid arm raises. The pain group had less variability in the timing of internal-oblique activation, while the erector-spinae comparisons did not show the same significant difference. Timing variability was not significantly associated with pain or disability scores on the test day. This cross-sectional study compared activation timing during rapid arm raises [2].

A controlled experiment shows how this can happen at the shoulder. Salomoni and colleagues had people practice fast reaching movements against a robotic force field, with or without experimentally induced pain in the front of the shoulder, in the anterior deltoid[11]. Both groups reached the same final accuracy, but the pain group got there with a different strategy that used less activity in the shoulder and arm muscles. When they repeated the task immediately afterward, now pain-free, they kept the strategy they had developed while it hurt.

The experiment tested re-exposure right after the pain resolved, so it shows that a strategy learned in pain can carry into later performance. It does not show that the strategy becomes permanent. Whether a retained strategy matters depends on what it costs in the task, which is the question the rest of this article works through.

For a coach and clinician discussing a return to pressing, useful history includes what changed, when it changed, what the athlete was trying to avoid and which activities still feel restricted. “I started stopping higher because the bottom position hurt” is more informative than “my technique is broken.” It identifies a task, an earlier reason and a question that can be revisited.

Assess whether the athlete can choose another useful strategy when the task calls for it.

Shoulder recovery illustrates the difference between repair and strategy

In 48 patients after arthroscopic rotator cuff repair, scapular substitution decreased during the first year but remained greater than on the opposite, asymptomatic side. Observed substitution was associated with poorer shoulder outcome scores, selected ranges of motion and scaption strength [3].

Assess how the humerus, scapula and trunk contribute to the task, alongside strength, stiffness, symptoms and movement history.

Anatomical orientation · shoulder example

One reach draws on more than one moving part

Realistic anatomical illustration of the shoulder girdle and upper torso during a reach, showing the relationship of the upper arm, scapula and trunk.

Upper arm

The humerus changes position relative to the shoulder blade.

Shoulder blade

The scapula contributes to how the arm is positioned.

Trunk

The torso can change the position of the shoulder and hand in space.

Conceptual anatomy showing upper-arm, scapular and trunk contributions to a reach [3].

Use the opposite shoulder as one comparison while assessing whether the recovering side meets its intended demands with acceptable symptoms, sufficient capacity and control.

Returning to the Bench Press After Rotator Cuff Repair brings together the postoperative evidence, treating-team restrictions and progression of pressing exposure.

The goal is consistent performance with adaptable movement

Consistency makes attempts comparable. An athlete can preserve the task’s important features while adjusting how muscles and joints share the work.

Van Dieën and colleagues describe varied changes in muscle activity, timing and kinematics in low back pain. Their proposed spectrum of tighter and looser control considers the advantages and costs of each strategy [4].

Match control to the task: a heavy press needs a repeatable base, while reaching or changing direction may call for more movement options. Introduce variation deliberately within the athlete’s permitted range and capacity.

Conceptual decision map

Evaluate the strategy against the current task

Current constraints

What is permitted, physically available and required by the task?

Useful solution

What does the present strategy let the person accomplish?

Available alternatives

Can another solution be performed and retained when appropriate?

Relevant costs

Does the strategy restrict participation, performance or tolerable exposure?

Four questions for reassessing a movement strategy in its current task.

The distinction matters in a bench press. Repeatable grip, range and touch point define the comparison, as described in Velocity Loss, Fatigue & Bench-Press Adaptation. That standard does not require treating every small adjustment as a failed motor pattern. A change earns attention because it affects the intended task or the athlete's response, not simply because it differs from the first repetition.

The Hub's proposed shoulder dysfunction and load-intolerance framework treats movement adaptation as a variable response within a larger system. This article develops that part of the model: an observed adjustment may help, cost something or do both, and its value has to be judged in the task where it occurs.

Capacity makes an option possible; practice makes it usable

Strength, range, endurance and coordination ask related but different questions. A strength test asks how much force can be produced under its conditions. A range test asks what positions are available. A practiced task asks whether those resources can be organized at the right time, at the required speed and with the information present in that situation.

In a small, uncontrolled study, nine volunteers with recurrent low back pain practiced transversus-abdominis contractions with ultrasound feedback and a four-week home program. Changes in trunk-activation timing and activity patterns during rapid arm movements and walking were retained at six months [5].

The useful distinction is between demonstrating a change during instruction and retaining it later. A person who performs differently only while watching a screen or receiving a cue has shown responsiveness. A person who can use the solution later, without that support, provides stronger evidence that the option has become available through learning.

Build capacity and skill together when both are needed. Strength can make an option achievable; practice helps the athlete use it in the intended task. Track each outcome.

If shoulder-strength testing improves but the athlete remains hesitant during the descent, assess that phase and ask what they experience. Practice Becomes Pattern explains how retention and transfer testing can track the skill.

Practice the activities that remain limited

A larger clinical trial provides direct evidence that practicing meaningful tasks can improve function. Van Dillen and colleagues randomized 154 adults with chronic nonspecific low back pain; 149 who received treatment entered the analysis. Participants received six weekly, one-hour sessions of either person-specific motor skill training in functional activities or strength and flexibility exercise. [6]

Disability, measured with the modified Oswestry Disability Questionnaire (0–100; higher scores indicate greater disability), favored motor skill training by 7.9 points immediately after treatment and by 5.7 points at twelve months. The training used challenging activities selected with the participant, adjusted the difficulty and reduced external feedback.

Randomized trial · van Dillen et al., 2021

Disability scores favored functional motor skill training

Difference between treatments on the 0–100 modified Oswestry Disability Questionnaire. A positive value here means a lower disability score with motor skill training.

Between-treatment score difference · points favoring motor skill training

View exact values and study context
Model-based contrasts: strength/flexibility score minus motor skill training score
Assessment Difference, points 95% CI, points P value
After treatment 7.9 4.7–11.0 <.001
6 months 5.6 2.1–9.1 .002
12 months 5.7 2.2–9.1 .001

154 adults with chronic nonspecific low back pain were randomized; 149 began treatment and entered the analysis (74 motor skill training; 75 strength/flexibility). Each program involved six weekly one-hour sessions. Differences are the authors’ model-based estimates in Table 2; they are not simple subtractions of the published sample means.

Bars show between-treatment score differences; black whiskers show 95% confidence intervals. Both treatments improved function [6].

Apply the finding to the activity that remains difficult

Practice the activity that remains difficult within the person’s clinical plan. Track whether it becomes easier to perform, needs less assistance or can be repeated more reliably. Choose outcomes that matter in daily life or sport.

Locate the difficulty within the lift

Assess the lift by phase: setup, initiation, descent, transition, completion and recovery between attempts. The treating team determines which phases may be tested and how to interpret the response.

Exposure can update expectations as well as physical tolerance

Avoidance can respect current capacity or a necessary restriction. When those conditions change, reassess the activity and the athlete’s expectations about it.

Leeuw and colleagues randomized 85 people with disabling nonspecific chronic low back pain and at least moderate pain-related fear to exposure in vivo or operant graded activity. Exposure produced greater reductions in catastrophizing and perceived harmfulness of activities, but the trial did not establish superior improvements in disability, main complaints, pain intensity or daily activity levels. Outcomes were assessed after treatment and at six months. [7]

Exposure compares an activity’s expected consequences with experience; graded activity organizes progressive participation. Select the task and dose with the clinician and track the outcome that matters to the person.

Define the expected consequence

A useful discussion begins with an understandable prediction: “What do you expect will happen in this task?” The answer may be pain, loss of control, inability to finish, embarrassment or concern about reinjury. Those are different problems. A clinician can evaluate whether the proposed task is appropriate and what would count as informative experience. The purpose is not to pressure the person into overriding symptoms or medical restrictions.

For example, a cleared athlete who expects to lose control in an approved range can test that expectation through a supervised, manageable exposure. Track control and confidence across repeated attempts.

Use the response to guide reassessment

Improvement should not depend on convincing someone that pain is unreal or that all symptoms have a psychological cause. Symptoms, capacity, expectations and task demands can be considered together. If the response is unexpected or function deteriorates, that observation belongs in reassessment. Exposure is an opportunity to learn within an appropriate plan, not a test of willingness to endure.

Feedback should help the person solve the task

In an acute single-leg-hop experiment with 16 patients after ACL reconstruction, external-focus instructions were associated with greater knee flexion at initial contact and peak flexion, greater total motion and longer time to peak flexion on the reconstructed side than internal-focus instructions [8].

Test the cue with the learner. A body-position cue may help one person; a target or movement-effect cue may help another. Check whether the task improves and whether it can later be performed with less prompting.

Feedback can answer two questions. Knowledge of the result tells the person whether the goal was achieved: the target was reached or the repetition met the agreed range. Information about performance describes how it happened: the descent accelerated unexpectedly or the touch point changed. Either can be useful, but an overload of simultaneous corrections can make it difficult to know which change mattered.

Choose one task question, offer a clear cue and ask the athlete what changed. Then repeat the approved task without the cue. Reduce feedback as the athlete becomes able to recognize and reproduce the solution independently.

Change the task deliberately and test what carries over

Retraining is more informative when the task is described precisely. In lifting, the implement, stance or grip, support, range, load, tempo and fatigue endpoint all matter to the comparison. Changing several at once may produce a successful attempt while leaving the reason uncertain. Holding most features steady makes it easier to see what the person has learned or what demand remains difficult.

Specific motor-control exercise can be useful without being uniquely necessary. A Cochrane review of 29 trials involving 2,431 people with chronic nonspecific low back pain found benefits compared with minimal intervention, but no clinically important superiority over other forms of exercise across the outcomes and follow-up periods examined. The review searched evidence through April 2015 [9].

Choose practice conditions for the current goal: build capacity, develop another movement option, reduce dependence on feedback or tolerate more of the task.

Retention and transfer then become concrete checks. Retention asks whether the approved movement can be performed after time away from instruction. Transfer asks whether the learning helps when a relevant feature changes. For a lifter, that might eventually mean a different permitted load, an ordinary training environment or completing the agreed number of sets. Coordinate those checks with the return plan.

Changing the environment can make a movement easier to discover. It can also make the practiced task different from the intended one. Constraints Shape Movement explains that relationship. The important record is what the person can do under which conditions, followed by whether the ability remains when those conditions become closer to the target.

Return includes participation, skill and repeatable exposure

The 2016 Bern return-to-sport consensus describes return as a continuum coordinated with recovery and rehabilitation, rather than an isolated decision at the end. It emphasizes collaboration among clinicians, athletes and coaches and the multiple factors that enter a return decision. The consensus emphasizes individualized, collaborative return decisions [10].

For compensation, that framing makes the target explicit. Being able to participate in modified training, perform the intended lift once and sustain ordinary training demands are different achievements. A strategy can be useful for the first and need further development for the others. None should be dismissed because it falls short of the final performance goal.

Separate the question from the evidence used to answer it
Question Relevant observation What remains separate
Is this exposure appropriate now? Current clinical assessment and agreed restrictions. Whether the athlete has practiced it.
Can the task be organized? Performance under defined, approved conditions. Maximum capacity and sustained training tolerance.
Is the solution available independently? Performance after a delay and without continual cueing. Readiness for every speed, load or context.
Can participation be sustained? Response across repeated exposures and recovery between them. A guarantee about future injury.

The clinical team and athlete select task-relevant tests. For bench pressing, these may include a controlled descent, a defined pause and a repeatable setup. Field sports may also require decisions under time pressure.

Nor must return always mean reproducing the exact preinjury strategy. Goals, anatomy, capacity and preferences can change. The useful outcome is a workable relationship between what the athlete wants to do, what the body currently permits and what can be performed and recovered from repeatedly.

Keep what works and expand what the person can choose

Compare the same task before and after a proposed change. Record the movement, the athlete’s experience and the effect on participation. Keep changes that improve the outcome the athlete needs.

For an athlete using an approved shorter pressing range, reassessment may support keeping it, addressing a capacity limit or practicing a larger approved range. New or changing symptoms warrant further evaluation.

Use neutral, specific feedback: “You use more trunk motion near the end of that reach.” Ask what the athlete was trying to achieve and which alternatives feel available.

Preserve useful protection while developing additional options at the appropriate stage. Test those options in the activities that matter to the athlete.

The Equipment Is Part of the Motor-Learning Environment examines how the physical setting shapes practice opportunities. Follow the athlete’s ability to perform, retain and adapt useful movement options as those conditions change.

References

  1. Moseley GL, Hodges PW. (2006). Reduced variability of postural strategy prevents normalization of motor changes induced by back pain: a risk factor for chronic trouble? Behavioral Neuroscience, 120(2), 474–476. doi:10.1037/0735-7044.120.2.474. ↩
  2. Jacobs JV, Henry SM, Nagle KJ. (2009). People with chronic low back pain exhibit decreased variability in the timing of their anticipatory postural adjustments. Behavioral Neuroscience, 123(2), 455–458. doi:10.1037/a0014479. ↩
  3. Baumgarten KM, Osborn R, Schweinle WE, Zens MJ, Helsper EA. (2018). Scapular substitution after rotator cuff repair correlates with postoperative patient outcome. International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy, 13(4), 687–699. Original source. ↩
  4. van Dieën JH, Reeves NP, Kawchuk G, van Dillen LR, Hodges PW. (2019). Motor control changes in low back pain: divergence in presentations and mechanisms. Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy, 49(6), 370–379. doi:10.2519/jospt.2019.7917. ↩
  5. Tsao H, Hodges PW. (2008). Persistence of improvements in postural strategies following motor control training in people with recurrent low back pain. Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology, 18(4), 559–567. doi:10.1016/j.jelekin.2006.10.012. ↩
  6. van Dillen LR, Lanier VM, Steger-May K, Wallendorf M, Norton BJ, Civello JM, et al. (2021). Effect of motor skill training in functional activities vs strength and flexibility exercise on function in people with chronic low back pain: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Neurology, 78(4), 385–395. doi:10.1001/jamaneurol.2020.4821. ↩
  7. Leeuw M, Goossens MEJB, van Breukelen GJP, de Jong JR, Heuts PHTG, Smeets RJEM, et al. (2008). Exposure in vivo versus operant graded activity in chronic low back pain patients: results of a randomized controlled trial. Pain, 138(1), 192–207. doi:10.1016/j.pain.2007.12.009. ↩
  8. Gokeler A, Benjaminse A, Welling W, Alferink M, Eppinga P, Otten B. (2015). The effects of attentional focus on jump performance and knee joint kinematics in patients after ACL reconstruction. Physical Therapy in Sport, 16(2), 114–120. doi:10.1016/j.ptsp.2014.06.002. ↩
  9. Saragiotto BT, Maher CG, Yamato TP, Costa LO, Menezes Costa LC, Ostelo RW, et al. (2016). Motor control exercise for chronic non-specific low-back pain. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2016(1), CD012004. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD012004. ↩
  10. Ardern CL, Glasgow P, Schneiders A, Witvrouw E, Clarsen B, Cools A, et al. (2016). 2016 consensus statement on return to sport from the First World Congress in Sports Physical Therapy, Bern. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(14), 853–864. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2016-096278. ↩
  11. Salomoni SE, Marinovic W, Carroll TJ, Hodges PW. (2019). Motor strategies learned during pain are sustained upon pain-free reexposure to task. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 51(11), 2334–2343. doi:10.1249/MSS.0000000000002059. ↩